Premium

Non-Simultaneous exchange 14 nights Feb 2026

Julie Verified

15 exchanges134 nights17 feedback

Lauren and Michael welcomed us with open arms to their island paradise! It was great to try out all the restaurants they recommended on St Thomas and to spend lots of time admiring the views from their home —which are better than anyplace we visited on the island! Lauren surprised me with a home made birthday treat during our stay! Thank you for a wonderful experience getting to know the Virgin Islands!

Non-Reciprocal exchange 7 nights Jan 2026

Jean Verified

5 exchanges55 nights6 feedback

It's impossible to over state how special Michael and Lauren's place is. The view is magical, the space is bright and has everything you need. It is very close to Magen's Bay Beach and not far from other beaches and restaurants. I can't imagine why you would stay anywhere else on St. Thomas! Mike and Lauren were on site most of the time and were always easy to communicate with. Our flight was delayed and we ended up arriving in the dark. Lauren put together a video to help us find our way in the dark which was incredibly helpful. We felt very well taken care of in all respects. We would return to Mike and Lauren's place in a heartbeat!

Non-Simultaneous exchange 7 nights Dec 2025

Sally Verified

7 exchanges64 nights8 feedback

Stunning, beautiful, and more than we could have wished for Lauren and Michael’s home on St Thomas was a pleasure in every way, starting with the views and the easy way to relax on the deck after a day at the beach and exploring the island. We were lucky to be able to meet Michael on our last day and enjoyed our conversation about traveling and our great experiences with PLU We look forward to hosting Lauren and Michael at our home in Taos. (Or Boulder, listing coming soon) and appreciate their generosity very much Thanks for sharing Blue Mare with us What a treat!

Hospitality exchange 4 nights Nov 2025

Barbara & Christine Verified

12 exchanges62 nights13 feedback

We have such fond memories of our stay at your beautiful home last year, and we’ll truly miss staying with you next year. Sorry we didn’t get to see you this time, Lauren—Michael was a wonderful host as always. Best wishes to you both as you settle into your new home.

Non-Reciprocal exchange 3 nights May 2025

Melissa Verified

24 exchanges128 nights21 feedback

Michael and Lauren's home overlooking Magen's Bay is stunning! We spent almost a week discovering beaches and could have easily spent another week on this beautiful island! We took the ferry over to St John and Coral Bay and Trunk Bay. Michael and Lauren's Mare Blue home had all the comforts and was beautifully decorated. We enjoyed returning to their home in the evenings to enjoy their huge deck space overlooking Magen's Bay and the beautiful boats in the bay! Hadd it not been for PLU, I would never have gotten to take such a magical trip. I loved every moment at their PLU and St Thomas!

Non-Simultaneous exchange 14 nights Mar 2025

Angela Verified

5 exchanges57 nights7 feedback

My daughter and I had a fabulous time at Lauren and Michael’s gorgeous home in St Thomas! I could hardly believe how wonderful this spacious home was - the views alone were breathtaking and the rooms were beautiful, fully equipped with all we could need including coffee makers, beach chairs, beach towels and so much more. Lauren kindly took us on a tour of the high spots on the island - it was lovely having them upstairs to offer advice on where to go. There are ample guidebooks there and Lauren offered advice on restaurants and beaches etc. The closest beautiful beach is just 5 minutes drive away. If you are lucky enough to be offered an exchange with Lauren and Michael, do not hesitate! You’ll need a car - would advise a Jeep! Thank you so much Lauren and Michael, looking forward to hosting you in Marblehead!

Non-Simultaneous exchange 14 nights Feb 2025

Fulvio Verified

9 exchanges128 nights16 feedback

Michael and Lauren's house is gorgeous! The interior is cozy and well organized but its strong point is the outdoor space, overlooking the bay it offers you a spectacular view: white beach, sea with a thousand shades of blue, rainbows, full moon. A dream! And then, what made this holiday special: the kindness, availability, courtesy of Lauren and Michael who, although without intrusiveness, made us part of a "little piece" of their lives. Together we had lunch, we took a boat ride, we celebrated on the beach with their friends the "thank god it's Friday", we shared time chatting. When we started the home exchange experience, more than 18 years ago, we were looking for just that: yes, of course, to see new places, but also to meet new people and make new friends. Sometimes it has been possible, this is one of those times. I am sure that with Lauren and Michael we will have the opportunity to meet again. In the meantime we can only thank them for this wonderful experience.

Non-Simultaneous exchange 11 nights Jan 2025

Craig & Kate Verified

2 exchanges27 nights3 feedback

Our visit to St. Thomas was nothing short of spectacular, and this home exceeded every expectation. From the moment we arrived, we were captivated by the breathtaking views—panoramic vistas of Magens Bay Beach stretched out below, framed by stunning sunsets that made us feel like we were on top of the world. The spacious patio, conveniently located off the guest suites, was the perfect place to soak it all in. Every beach day felt like a gift, and we returned home with incredible memories—especially one unforgettable photograph of the brightest double rainbow we’ve ever seen. This stay was pure paradise!

Non-Reciprocal exchange 8 nights Dec 2024

Lynn and Pete Verified

23 exchanges223 nights27 feedback

What a wonderful stay in paradise! Lauren and Michael’s home is on a hill overlooking one of the most beautiful bays and beaches in the Virgin Islands. Our little apartment was comfortable and well-appointed and had everything we needed. The deck was a great place to hang out and view the yachts on the water and the people down on Magens Bay Beach. We spent several days at that beach, enjoying the peace and quiet when cruise ships were not in port. We took the car ferry over to St. John to visit the National Park and stayed one night in Cruz Bay. The island is much less built up than St. Thomas and the beaches were spectacular. Driving around the islands was an interesting challenge – on the left of the narrow, curvy, hilly roads in a left-hand drive car! But people were courteous and gave way. The best part of the trip was getting to know Lauren and Michael. They were gracious and helpful and we had a fun evening by their pool, watching the sunset and sharing PLU adventure stories and cocktails.

Non-Reciprocal exchange 5 nights Nov 2024

Barbara & Christine Verified

12 exchanges62 nights13 feedback

Lauren was an exceptional host! Our time on St. Thomas was absolutely beautiful and unforgettable. The accommodations were pristine, and the view was nothing short of spectacular. If you ever have the chance to stay with Lauren and Michael, don’t hesitate—it’s truly a dream home. We can’t wait to return the favor and host these wonderful people. This experience perfectly captures the spirit of PLU. Thank you, Lauren and Michael, for your warmth, generosity, and hospitality!

Simultaneous exchange 14 nights May 2024

Melanie

1 exchange28 nights

Michael and Lauren’s home was simply magical. We were completely overwhelmed by the view and beautiful setting. The apartments were really comfortable and well equipped with everything we needed. We had lots of BBQs watching the sunset and explored many of the Island’s stunning beaches. Michael and Lauren were perfect hosts and went above and beyond to answer all our questions. We had the trip of a lifetime and couldn’t have asked for nicer hosts.

Non-Simultaneous exchange 9 nights Feb 2024

Anne & Gregor Verified

7 exchanges93 nights10 feedback

Michael and Lauren’s beautiful home on St. Thomas was our first PLU exchange as guests. Future exchanges are going to have mighty big shoes to fill! The photos don’t begin to do the space justice. It’s very comfortable and stylish, with everything provided for a perfect beach holiday - beach chairs, towels, coolers and ice packs. It was so great not having to pack those things. And the outdoor space will take your breath away, there are views for miles, and Magen’s bay, one of the prettiest beaches in the Caribbean (if not the world) is right at your feet. We could have spent the entire week just on that beach. It has parking, restrooms, and a bar and restaurant. If you go to the far end, you’ll pretty much have the place to yourselves. And the house just a short drive to grocery stores and plenty of good restaurants. Michael is a boat captain, so we were able to arrange a half day boat charter with him, which was the highlight of the trip. We had lunch at Lovango, a gorgeous resort across the water from Cruz Bay, and then snorkeled in some beautiful spots where we saw so much marine life and were able to observe sea turtles up close. Magic! Lauren and Michael are wonderful exchange partners, communication was excellent and I feel like we’ve made new friends. We really hope to return to St. Thomas, and we are looking forward to hosting them in Italy later this year. This was everything we hoped for when we joined PLU!